OAKLAND, California: Microsoft’s potential acquisition of short-video app TikTok carries myriad risks, thrusting it into the politically fraught social media business and China-US conflict amid increased scrutiny of Big Tech companies.
But the deal could help Microsoft build on its US$27 billion purchase of LinkedIn to become a bigger player in Internet advertising now dominated by Facebook and Google.
Microsoft on Sunday (Aug 2) said it aims to complete a deal by Sep 15 for TikTok’s US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand operations. It is likely to have an edge in pricing negotiations as the US is effectively forcing TikTok’s Chinese parent, ByteDance, to sell by threatening to ban the app as a security risk.
TikTok has taken teenagers around the world by storm and emerged as a significant competitor to Facebook and Google’s YouTube. But like rivals, TikTok faces substantial new costs for content moderation as the spread of misinformation and allegations of political bias roil social media.
Increased oversight costs accounted for much of the 10-percentage-point drop in gross profit margins for Facebook and Google’s parent company Alphabet over the last three-and-a-half years, Refinitiv data showed.
“Does Microsoft really want to own an app that breeds conspiracy theories in tweens?” said Hank Green, YouTube star and chief executive of educational media company Complexly.
Green said TikTok removes content to maintain “a certain feel”, and could face public challenges over such decisions more often under a bigger name such as Microsoft.
At US$1.55 trillion, Microsoft is the world’s second-largest company by market capitalisation after Apple but has in recent years faced less criticism than peers over antitrust, data protection and China projects.
Microsoft has done several big deals since Satya Nadella became chief executive in 2014, with acquisitions including world-building game Minecraft and job search social network LinkedIn. They have fared better than those under predecessor Steve Ballmer, whose failed deals included Nokia Oyj’s phone business.
The LinkedIn acquisition in 2016, for 50 per cent above its share price, was Nadella’s biggest and riskiest. Microsoft shares fell 3 per cent when it was announced with analysts expressing concern about slowing revenue growth and an expected cap on usage.
Some concerns may have been overblown. Microsoft has avoided antitrust and privacy scrutiny with a cautious approach to connecting LinkedIn to other products, such as Outlook, and analysts have largely viewed the deal as a success in terms of synergies.
Though the COVID-19 pandemic has slowed sales, LinkedIn ad revenue was among Microsoft’s fastest-growing between 2017 and 2019 as the global economy roared.
Overall, LinkedIn has generated US$14.3 billion in revenue for Microsoft through ads and subscriptions, though analysts estimate it remains unprofitable.
TikTok is a bigger gamble because it caters to a less-affluent audience than LinkedIn, where advertisers typically pay more to attract wealthier consumers. TikTok’s ad sales team and technology also are far less mature than LinkedIn’s were, and TikTok faces greater competition.
About 11 per cent of US adults use TikTok at least once per week, versus 49 per cent for YouTube and 62 per cent for Facebook, showed a survey last month by tech consultancy Vorhaus Advisors.
LinkedIn came to Microsoft at 13-years-old with 11,000 employees and 105 million monthly users globally.
Six-year-old TikTok, by contrast, has about 1,000 US employees and has been downloaded 226 million times in the four countries targeted by Microsoft’s deal, showed data from app tracker Sensor Tower.
LinkedIn “was bought on domination of a sector, good revenue, and good margins”, said Mike Vorhaus, head of Vorhaus Advisers. “TikTok is going to be valued based on its incredible user growth and mobile advertising revenue opportunities.”
TikTok would make Microsoft relevant among both young engineers looking for a hip place to work and advertisers clamouring for alternatives to Facebook and Google.
Green, the YouTube star, said he doubted Microsoft ownership would hurt TikTok, noting he amassed 600,000 TikTok followers since he began posting a month ago.
“I don’t see anything at all standing in the way,” he said.